Research Papers

Humanitarian Deterrence: Affective Legitimation of Coercive Policies in Response to Russia’s War Against Ukraine

Russia’s full-scale invasion of Ukraine generated an extensive humanitarian
mobilization in Western democracies in which compassion for civilian suffering became
increasingly intertwined with support for sanctions, military assistance, and long-term security
commitments. This article conceptualizes this configuration as humanitarian deterrence: a
mode of legitimizing coercive policies in which humanitarian emotions and moral narratives
provide an affective infrastructure for sustaining deterrence, and develops the concept through
Luc Boltanski’s politics of compassion and Arlie Hochschild’s theory of feeling rules. Drawing
on an interpretive analysis of political rhetoric and a secondary analysis of public-opinion data
from the European Union and the United States between 2022 and 2025, the study
reconstructs an affective-moral chain linking humanitarian shock, narrative articulation,
political translation, and the contested normalization of prolonged support. The analysis
suggests that compassion, empathy, and moral outrage can operate as a bridge between care
and coercion by rendering sanctions, arms deliveries, and other security measures intelligible
as expressions of responsibility toward the victim of aggression rather than solely as responses
to strategic threat. The article argues that humanitarian deterrence constitutes a contingent
rather than irreversible form of political legitimacy, whose durability depends on the continued
reproduction of moral narratives, institutional trust, and political consensus and may weaken
under conditions of economic pressure, partisan counter-mobilization, declining public
attention, and competing interpretations of responsibility

More Research Paperss